Saturday, January 19, 2013

Value Traps & NTA Plays


Following Inch Kenneth meteoric surge, some readers have been so kind to send me emails about other great value stocks, e.g. Landmarks, Selangor Dredging, etc ... Dear all, stocks that trade at massive discounts are aplenty. You cannot just point to any one and say that's a good investment. It has a lot to do with proper usage of capital by investors. Why lock up your capital in a non performing great asset? The key is there must be a CATALYST to unlock value, something must be happening to unlock that value.




Those who have been in the markets long enough will understand the term "value trap". It is when you buy and hold something for the longest time because there is great inherent value. However the investor does not know when will the hidden values be unlock by management and/or owners. 

Hence investors who are wiser will always bear in mind the "value trap", being locked into something for the longest time, sometimes years. Let's look at: 

Kuchai Development 

Its basically a holding company. Its got a substantial stake of 26% in palm oil Sg Bagan and a highly attractive 3m shares of Great Eastern (traded now btw S$15-16). All in the total net asset value for Kuchai Development is around RM260m. It has 120.7m shares (50 sen), which makes for a NAV of RM2.47. Guess what's the share price??? Its just 1.20. How to go wrong?

Technically you have to outlive the owners or wait till they finally decide to do something with their shares. When looking at a value company, the first thing to check is the shareholdings level. For Kuchai: 

Kluang Rubber 41.9% 
Sg Bagan 9.38% 
Lee Foundation 4.18% 
Kota Trading 1.77% 



The top 3 are basically the same group of people and they made doubly sure they have more than 50% as that will stop anyone thinking of raiding the company. So if someone comes along and collect shares and then make a G.O. at RM1.60, he/she will not succeed as long as the controlling shareholders do not sell. They will probably sell if someone comes along and offer a substantive premium to NAV, say RM2.60-2.80 or thereabouts. The value is in the NAV and then the listing vehicle as a value add. 

Once the owner controls more than 50%, there's very little you can do. If you can locate a value company and there is ample free float, plus the controlling shareholder holds less than 35%, then I bet you that many vultures will be circling to take over the company, thus narrowing the gap between NAV and the share price.

It might be OK to hold on forever if the company pays a decent dividend, but in Kuchai's case it paid 0.8 sen in 2008 and 0.45 sen in 2009. If you take the share price of 80 sen  then, that works out to be a paltry dividend yield of 1% and 0.56%. Really no incentive to own this stock.


Stock               Share Price / NAV
Minho                 0.54 / 2.67
Mitrajaya            0.44 / 0.79
Pasdec                0.32 / 1.81
Advance Synergy  0.15 / 0.89
Majuperak           0.28 / 1.23
Eupe                   0.57 / 1.99
Focal Aims           0.37 / 1.17
Xian Leng            0.31 / 0.91
PW Cons             0.45 / 2.10
BCB                   0.40 / 1.69
Ekowood             0.18 / 0.73
Kia Lim               0.34 / 1.08
Prinsiptek            0.22 / 1.00
Rex Industry        0.62 / 1.92
KPSC                  0.39 / 1.26
Mycron Steel        0.34 / 1.43
Jerasia Capital     0.56 / 1.44
Cymao                0.31 / 1.47


I can go on and on ... for another 100 more at least ...



CAVEATS

These are not recommendations at all, just to highlight those with massive discounts to NTA. Besides the discount, one must look at a few things:
a) the quality of assets under its NTA, whether they are readily realisable or industry specific sunk cost (e.g. steel mills)
b) the real burn rate of an imploding company, many companies with discounts are because investors are dumping stocks of a deteriorating company which will be making significant amount of losses over the next few years just by hanging around, an imploding business model (let's not mention names la) .... then the discount is actually JUSTIFIED
c) there are material litigation which may cause future losses and liabilities



Dear SC & Bursa: I really think that there is a strong case for the SC and Bursa to come down hard on Kuchai because it does not resemble a normal company with on-going businesses. Its strictly a holding company. It does NOT allow shareholders to participate in the growth of the company, it just holds the stakes forever. It does NOTHING to extract value from their inherent value. 

To me, its like a company which has sold all businesses and sits on cash. In this case, the cash is the assets. Yes, we are treading on uncharted waters here when I advocate that SC & Bursa put in a proactive move to reinvigorate stocks like Kuchai ... but we can certainly draw up some stringent parameters, and if they are long drawn out inactive management presiding over deep value assets ... then issue a GOOD no-UMA, further inaction give them a delisting notice. We already have rules that forces companies to have a decent free float, we have rules that prohibits a company from sitting on cash forever, rules that warn companies if they are too inactive in volume traded ... all wanting a properly regularised market place to safeguard investors. Companies like Kuchai makes a mockery of being a listed company.

For companies like Kuchai, I would suggest that they need to sell down their company from above 50% effective stake to below 40% within 2 years, and then to below 35% within 4 years. One, it makes for better liquidity, two... it puts the company in play, three ... the owners will finally do something to extract value instead of doing nothing. Sounds like a great idea but will never get passed for being too radical. Still, worth thinking about it than doing nothing.

Some may say so is Berkshire Hathaway - in Buffett's case, he actively manages his positions, positions will be sold once they reach above fair value and vice versa. Kuchai's position makes a mockery of being a listed counter - anyone in their right mind would be 100x better off to invest directly into Great Eastern or Sg Bagan - there is absolutely no value to its existence.



Friday, January 18, 2013

Grandjean Truffles


A good friend of mine has been bringing in the exclusive and "to-die-for" handmade whisky truffles from Switzerland for sometime now. She has a steady flow of happy clientele who will order tons of them for gift-giving during festive seasons. Good things should be shared, if you are cracking your heads over what to send as gifts for this CNY, you should seriously consider Grandjean Truffles.

Happy Chinese New Year to all chocolate lovers and welcome to the Year of the Snake! Although it might seem an age since we celebrated the arrival of the calendar new year and moved in 2013, the most important festival in Chinese culture is now upon us and it is time to celebrate once again.

The Chinese New Year is not only the most important Chinese celebration but it is also the longest so make sure you celebrate it in style this year by offering high quality but affordable luxury gifts to your friends, family and colleagues.
 

Whisky truffles gift black box – RM 160


Contains 10 pieces of whisky truffles 


Choose our famous GRANDJEAN handmade Whisky Truffles! Delicious and rich, these truffles are a beautiful gift to help put the events of the past year behind you, starting afresh and forgetting old grudges.

Be ready for the first new moon of the lunar calendar and celebrate the Chinese New Year in style with us!

Order your Grandjean Whisky Truffles now and get them delivered a few days before CNY.

Petit G  RM100







Baby G  RM50


 PLACE YOUR ORDER NOW!


Pickup at Centerpoint @ Bandar Utama at no extra cost.

Delivery charges will apply for delivery to other areas within the Klang Valley.


So Much For History.

History says Jan. OpEx is normally Red.
But this year the history was turned upside down, as was last year.
And all the day trading bears got slaughtered, again.
I sometimes visit a day trading forum of a TA site and I see folks animately discussing VIX trend line,( a new low of 12.31) T2111, USHL5, NYHGH, so on and so forth. The conclusion is that a Top is around the corner and things are about to crash.

I still hope for some sort of correction beginning of next week but definitely no crash. By the way, does any one remember what I wrote about VIX a week back? If you don't , here is a link:
Expect VIX to reach low double digit

The problem with these TA guys are same as that of Robert Prechter or ZH.
They are never wrong, just little early.
And TA need not be complicated. It works when you can make it simple so that anyone can understand it.
Prechter has been early with his S&P500 crash call for the last 5 years as has been ZH. May be one of these days it will really crash and then they can say "Told you so". But I doubt anyone would be left to short the market then, because by then everyone would have blown up their capital with these wrong calls.

Today gold and silver faced the resistance and retreated a bit.
Let us look at the chart of gold.
This is a simple chart with trend lines and Fib info. Easy to understand that gold is facing a resistance at $1700 and that is what we saw yesterday and today, when gold came close to $ 1700 and retreated. Very soon it will break this triangle and I am on the camp that it will break to the upside and run away. So we will be patient with our long gold position for many months to come. While there is a short term top in gold, the weekly cycles are up.

Nat. Gas is presenting a paradox. Seasonality and longer term cycles are down but having closed above $ 3.38, the price actions indicate that it wants to retest the last high before rolling over. As I do not trade against the cycles, I will not go long here. Rather, I will wait for the price action to exhaust itself and then take a short trade again.

Coffee futures are grinding higher but is still away from the long term buy signal. But cycles are close to bottom and specially in such situations we can expect whipsaws. The coffee ETF, JO is presently at around $35.10 and I think a buy signal would come around $ 38.75 or so. Please send your feedback on this one.

Oil has reached a point where I do not expect much short term gain and is looking a bit stretched here. A correction to the $ 88-$ 89 level is needed before we can go long oil again.

All in all, a very interesting week. There are some very interesting trends developing and Sunday Newsletter will highlight some of them to the subscribers. As always, let's not front run because this beast has some more energy to run.
Have a great weekend folks.



Thursday, January 17, 2013

Counter Point

For those of you who have been brain wasted by ZH and other prophets of doom and gloom, here is something of a counterpoint:
Ray of Hope by Ned Davis
I am not saying we should rush to buy stocks.
I am just saying: keep an open mind.

P.S. Its now almost noon per Eastern time. I find it odd that ZH was silent for almost 40 minutes ( 11.34-10.54) and had not come up with another story why everything will end badly. Running out of ideas or Top is really close and no longer a need to drive folks to short?

Wednesday, January 16, 2013

Things We Should Know & Embrace

Saw this from one of my blog links, An Undomesticated Blogspot, searched a bit more and found that there were tons of fascinating mini videos made by the same group. When you condense a lot of information into a few minutes, you have to make it witty, relevant and revealing for the WOW Factor ... these video have them all ... and I agree with the deeper implications of the basic truths they represent. Enjoy and embrace more clarity in your life.

WE ARE ALL FEMALE (so close ... yet so far yet so near, we all almost the same, so what to get so worked up over with gender bias and lifestyle choices ... same-same gene pool)




CAN MONEY BUY HAPPINESS (yes, of course, its the way you spend it)



THE POWER OF MUSIC (to me house music is not music, its torture chamber for Europeans)



THE POWER OF NAPS (just don't go past 30 minutes each time)

Deja-Vu?

Almost a repeat of last year.

The Indices keep grinding up while everyone calls for the top and correction.
Last year, the Jan OpEx had a rare gain and so far this year, we have opened lower but sharply reversed for everyday of this OpEx week.
Historically Euro is weak during January but the history has been over written both last year and this year so far. Euro refuses to go any below 1.3200 and as a result, there is no sell signal in Euro.
So where do we go from here?
First thing first. We don't need to front run and short the market just because some of our favourite TA indicators are showing overbought.
Next, while the Indices can definitely grind higher, just like last year, the risk;reward is not favour of huge gain without some correction.
In such situation I follow the rule:

Cash is King.

PM sector is on the verge of long term break-out (silver already broke out) and I would rather put my money in gold and silver than in equities. We are long PM from beginning of January and some selected commodity shares.

I think Coffee is making a long term bottom but I am waiting for confirmation. Nat. Gas trade which went against us, will come back to us in few days. And I like Oil long term. Bonds are making a bottom and TLT will most likely give a buy signal sometime soon. So you see, there are plenty of fish out there without bothering much about equities.

Regarding US Bonds, I think this is probably the last bounce we will see in bonds for many many years to come. So if you are long bond funds, you may think of getting out in the strength.

Equities are in the process of making a complex top but the top will come when everyone has given up and raised their hand in resignation. May be few weeks away but definitely not now. We may see some correction, we want to see correction but that may not be the start of the major drop in price. But for my plan to play out, we need that correction soon and I hope it arrives tomorrow. As I have written before, till SPX 1450 is taken out, we have nothing to worry and in fact would be a buy opportunity.

Lets wait for tomorrow and see how it plays out. In the mean time, we sit tight with our positions.

Thanks for sharing my thoughts. As always, stay frosty.


Tuesday, January 15, 2013

I Am Still Laughing!

Orlando the ginger cat

Purrrrrr-fect-stock-picking

And we do so much research for beating the S&P benchmark!

By the way, 61% of the hedge funds were below that vaunted S&P benchmark.

fund-manager-performance-vs-the-sp/

Why are we still paying 2 and 20?